• American Pie (1971) – This was McLean’s breakthrough album, containing the iconic title track “American Pie” which topped the Billboard Hot 100 chart. The album was a major critical and commercial success, reaching #1 on the Billboard 200 and being certified 4x Platinum.
• Playin’ Favorites (1973) – This covers album of traditional American folk and country songs was a commercial success, reaching the top 10 on the Billboard 200 chart.
• Playin’ Favorites Vol. 2 (1974) – Similar to the first Playin’ Favorites album, this covers collection was another Top 10 hit on the Billboard 200.
• Vincent (1972) – McLean’s second studio album, which contained his tribute song “Vincent (Starry Starry Night)” about the painter Vincent van Gogh. It was a critical success and reached the top 20 on the Billboard 200.
• Tapestry (1970) – McLean’s debut studio album, which contains early recordings of some of his signature songs like “And I Love You So.” While not a major commercial hit, it was well-received critically.

1. American Pie (1971)

Don McLean’s 1971 album American Pie is a defining piece of classic rock and folk music that has left a lasting impact on popular culture. The album’s title track, “American Pie,” is a cultural touchstone that reflects on the changing landscape of American music and society in the 1960s. The song’s iconic lyrics—“the day the music died”—refer to the tragic plane crash that killed Buddy Holly, Ritchie Valens, and J.P. Richardson, signaling a pivotal moment in rock history.

The album combines elements of rock, folk, and country, showcasing McLean’s songwriting prowess and storytelling ability. Tracks like “Vincent” pay tribute to painter Vincent van Gogh, highlighting McLean’s knack for weaving narratives that resonate with a wide audience. The album achieved commercial success, reaching number one on the Billboard 200, and its legacy continues to influence musicians and listeners alike. With its blend of poignant lyrics and timeless melodies, American Pie remains a cornerstone of 1970s music.

2. Playin’ Favorites (1973)

Playin’ Favorites showcases his love for traditional American folk and country music. Departing from his earlier work of original compositions, this album consists entirely of covers of classic folk and country songs, reflecting McLean’s musical influences. It includes his interpretations of timeless tracks, capturing the spirit of the genres with his distinct vocal style and acoustic arrangements.

The album highlights McLean’s deep connection to the roots of American music, as he pays homage to legendary songwriters and folk traditions. While not as commercially successful as his previous releases, Playin’ Favorites resonates with listeners who appreciate McLean’s authentic take on these well-known songs. It demonstrates his versatility as a performer and his ability to breathe new life into classic material. For fans of folk and country music, the album is a tribute to the enduring power of these genres and McLean’s passion for preserving their legacy.

3. Playin’ Favorites Vol. 2 (1974)

Playin’ Favorites Vol. 2 continues his exploration of traditional American folk and country music. Following the approach of the first Playin’ Favorites album, McLean delves into a collection of classic covers that pay homage to the roots of these genres. The album features his unique interpretations of well-known folk and country songs, showcasing his appreciation for the storytelling and musical traditions that have influenced his career.

With Playin’ Favorites Vol. 2, McLean reinforces his role as both a performer and a custodian of American musical heritage. His arrangements stay true to the original spirit of the songs while allowing his distinct voice and acoustic style to shine through. For listeners who enjoy authentic folk and country music, this album offers a heartfelt tribute to the genre’s rich history. It is a testament to McLean’s deep respect for the timeless qualities of folk and country, making it a compelling addition to his discography.

4. Vincent (1972)

Vincent (1972) showcases his lyrical prowess and emotional depth, best known for the poignant tribute to the painter Vincent van Gogh. The title track, often referred to as “Starry Starry Night,” reflects on van Gogh’s troubled life and artistry, becoming one of McLean’s most beloved songs. The album features a blend of folk, acoustic, and soft rock elements, with McLean’s signature storytelling style at the forefront.

McLean’s delicate guitar work and emotive vocals capture the essence of the themes he explores, from personal reflection to broader social commentary. While the title track remains the most recognized piece, the rest of the album offers a cohesive listening experience that delves into complex emotions and vivid imagery. The success of Vincent helped solidify McLean’s place in the 1970s music scene, resonating with audiences through its introspective lyrics and timeless melodies. This album continues to be celebrated for its artistic sincerity and McLean’s unique ability to convey powerful narratives through song.

5. Tapestry (1970)

Tapestry (1970), marks the beginning of his career as a singer-songwriter known for his introspective and poetic style. This album showcases McLean’s ability to blend folk, rock, and country elements, creating a sound that reflects the social and political climate of the time. Recorded in the wake of the 1960s counterculture movement, Tapestry explores themes of love, loss, and social change, with McLean’s evocative lyrics and acoustic guitar playing a central role.

The album laid the groundwork for McLean’s subsequent success and established him as a thoughtful voice in the folk music scene. His storytelling prowess and vocal sincerity are evident throughout the record, inviting listeners into a world of vivid imagery and heartfelt emotions. Although it didn’t achieve the same commercial success as his later works, Tapestry remains an important part of McLean’s discography, appreciated for its raw, honest expression and the depth of its lyrical content.